Here an explanation for those who have no clue about SMTP:
Mail Client ------> My Mail Provider ------> Recipient's Mail Provider
SMTP SMTP
The "Mail Client" usually uses a dial up IP address. This is often an IP
address which is on a Black List. Therefore the "Recipient's Mail
Provider" would not accept it directly. The "Mail Client" therefore
sends the mail to the "My Mail Provider". This host can authentificate
the mail: the mail must be from the domain the "My Mail Provider"
administrates and the E-Mail address must exist. A spammer cannot use
"My Mail Provider" as an open relay because he has not a valid account
on this server. The "My Mail Provider" sends the mail to "Recipient's
Mail Provider". The "Recipient's Mail Provider" accepts the mail
because
the "My Mail Provider" has a fixed IP address and this IP address is not
an a Black List.
For those who still do not understand why it is not a good idea for
Coditel to relay their customer's non xyz(a)coditel.lu addresses, here's
the explanation:
Unlike "My Mail Provider" Coditels relay could not ensure that I did not
fake my From field. Infact I could even use a non existent address (as
long the domain exists in the DNS). Coditel would essentially be an open
relay reserved for their own customers. The From field could be anything
a worm would find in a address database, Coditel's mail server could not
filter it.
Everybody understands?
I mean if you understand the SMTP protocol and the fact I do not want to
change my own E-Mail address everytime I change a dialup service, than
you will see that I use my dialup access in a *sensible* way.
And yes: The engineless car is waiting for you ;-))))))
Patrick Kaell
Show replies by date
What I forgot to add:
If Coditel would relay their customer's mail (maybe they even do it,
haven't tested it), then the other ISPs soon would have to put Coditel's
mail server to a Black List. At the moment they only have to do it for
Coditel's dialup address range! If Coditel's mail server only sends
Coditel addresses and my mail provider only sends my mails, it is enough
to have a Black List blocking all dialup address ranges to protect
against worms.
Now imagine servers like Coditel's mail server that are not on a Black
List relay mails generated by their customer's worms! Coditel cannot
check if the From: address is valid! Remember!
Yes, I do get emotional when somebody (who never has read a RFC document
about SMTP) says I would not use my dialup account correctly!
Patrick Kaell